With increasing concern among citizens about inequalities in society
the disagreement about measures to overcome this is also increasing.
VS – 01/2022
The Does Inequality Matter? study examines how people in OECD
countries think about inequality in their own country. As recently as the late
1980s/early 1990s, respondents believed that top earners earned five times as
much as low-income earners on average. Today, this perceived ratio of high to
low-income earners has risen to 8.
People's perception is not detached from reality
The study analyses the degree of
correlation between perceived and actual income inequality. In fact, the income
gap has widened over the past three decades and social mobility has stagnated
in many OECD countries. Income inequality also tends to be perceived as being greater
and rising in those countries, where measured income inequality is also higher
and rising.
Tolerance of inequality has also increased albeit to a lesser extent
The study examines attitudes toward
inequality and redistributive policies. Today, people generally believe that
top earners should earn four times as much as lower earners, compared with
three times in the late 1980s.
Differences between countries
At least 6 out of 10 OECD citizens believe
their government should do more to reduce the income gap between rich and poor
through taxes and transfers. Here, the more people are concerned about
inequality and perceive low social mobility, the greater their demand for
redistribution.
However, demands for policy measures also
depend heavily on notions about the effectiveness of policy and the
determinants of inequality. People are less likely to call for greater
redistribution if they think benefits are non-targeted, and they are less
supportive of progressive taxation if they are convinced of widespread
corruption.
The demand for more progressive taxation is
also lower if people consider inequalities to be justified by differences in
personal effort rather than by circumstances over which people have no control.
In Poland in 2018, for example, one in four believed that poverty primarily
stems from a lack of effort and has less to do with injustice. In Germany, only
four per cent of respondents held this view, in Austria six per cent and in
Belgium seven per cent. Accordingly, far fewer people in Poland called for more
progressive taxation (54 per cent) than in Germany (77 per cent), Austria (71
per cent) and Belgium (67 per cent).
In most countries, the gap between those
who perceive inequality to be high and those who perceive it to be low in all
likelihood has grown over the past three decades. What is striking here is an
increasing polarisation in people's views about inequalities in their country
within groups with similar socio-economic characteristics, such as income or
education level.