Remote work and its legal hurdles
EUROGIP Study on the Treatment of Occupational Accidents in Seven European Countries
UV – 05/2023
March this year, EUROGIP published a Study
on the Treatment of Remote Occupational Accidents, providing an overview of the situation in
seven European countries. EUROGIP is a public advocacy group for issues related
to the prevention and insurance of occupational accidents and diseases, founded
in 1991 by the French Health Insurance Fund for Workers (CNAMTS) and the
National Institute for Research and Safety (INRS). The subject of the study is
the legal handling of remote occupational accidents and the related questions
about the extent of insurance protection for employees and the specific
employer obligations for adequate remote occupational safety. The study focuses
on remote workplaces, i.e. working at a fixed workplace in the home
environment. Other forms of remote work are excluded.
European world of work in transition
The working world has undergone profound
changes in recent years. More employees than ever before worked from home
during the pandemic. In the future, according to EUROGIP, a large number of
workers in Europe will continue to work from home regularly or, in a hybrid
model, occasionally. According to the Framework Directive on Occupational
Safety and Health, employers should in principle remain responsible for the
health and safety of their workers even when they are working remotely. The
national design shows significant differences in the implementation. For example,
in Germany, Austria, France, Italy and Finland, legal regulations have been
established for the concept of occupational accident. In France and Spain, the
presumption that any accident at the workplace during working hours is
considered an occupational accident has also been applied to the remote
workplace. However, a differentiated solution is being sought in other
countries. However, there are many "grey areas" related to the
difficulty of clearly distinguishing between private and work-related activities
in the domestic environment in order to more clearly determine the employee's
insurance coverage. Therefore, not only is the handling of commuting accidents
inconsistent, but also the equipment of remote workplaces. In half of the
countries included in the study, the employer is not obliged to provide
ergonomic equipment. In Germany, the employer is already obliged to set up a
remote workplace, while Austria, for example, relies on tax benefits for
employees if they set up a remote workplace themselves.
The European social partners started
negotiations in 2022 to revise the European framework agreement on remote work,
which will cover, among other things, the right to adequate work equipment and
the right to disconnect.
German remote work regulations
The term remote work is legally defined in
Germany and means that the employer provides a permanently installed computer
workstation including furniture in the employee’s private space. The work
performance owed under the employment contract is protected by the statutory
accident insurance in the case of remote work. This also includes special
activities such as company sports or company community events should they be
conducted virtually. Austria and Italy have also opted for equivalent
protection at the remote workplace under certain conditions. It remains to be
seen whether and to what extent European initiatives will further influence
this in the future.